whole•some (adjective) conducive to moral or general well-being moth•er (noun) a female parent.


Friday, April 15, 2011

Viewer Input... Love or Murder? What's Your Opinion?

This morning a single mother in Massachusetts was sentenced to 8 to 10 years in prison for the attempted murder of her son.  


Kristen LaBrie, 38, was convicted of attempted murder on April 12, 2011 and will now serve time in prison.  She has also been ordered to serve five years on probation and to complete an anger management program. 


LaBrie’s son, Jeremy Fraser, died of leukemia in March of 2009 at the age of 9.  Fraser, an autistic child, was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma in 2006 when he was 6 years old.  His cancer was in remission but, progressed to Leukemia after LaBrie quit giving him his medications.  Doctors discovered that Fraser had not been administered his medications in 2008 and he was placed into the care of his father, Eric Fraser who later died of a motorcycle accident in 2010.


Sections from an article on boston.com…

LaBrie told jurors that she thought her son was cancer-free, and that she withheld the prescribed medication because of the pain it caused him.  LaBrie’s attorney, Kevin James also argued that his client was overwhelmed by raising Jeremy on her own, and that officials at Massachusetts General Hospital — where Jeremy was receiving care — should have done more to determine whether she was suitable to administer the treatments. “The child required more care than one person could give,’’ he said. “You have to make him sick [by giving him the drugs], but she failed to do it, she couldn’t do it . . . because she loved the child.’’  He added that she was depressed and overwhelmed by the care of Jeremy, who also had autism.


“He was a little boy, he was her little boy, and he had an opportunity for a miracle . . . and she took that from him, she stole that from him,’’ Assistant District Attorney Kate MacDougall said.  “That was not a tragic mistake,’’ MacDougall added, “That was not an accident. That was in every sense of the word criminal.’’  MacDougall, through the cross-examination of LaBrie, sought to paint the mother as an exaggerator who abused her child by withholding the medication. She also said LaBrie lied about administering the medications because she realized what she was doing was wrong.  MacDougall said in her closing argument that LaBrie did not show the emotions typical of a mother who lost her child, stating that she got a haircut and took vacations after losing custody of Jeremy to Eric Fraser. (to read the full article click here)


This subject is not new and it is very controversial.  In 2001 there was the case of Dennis and Lorie Nixon who went to prison, convicted of letting their teen-age daughter die.  Their Daughter, Shannon Nixon, 16, died of diabetes acidosis, a treatable condition in which her blood sugar levels soared twelve-fold.  She opted for prayer over medicine, fell into a coma and died.


There are many other parents that have been on trial for not seeking medical treatment for their children.  Some refuse due to religious beliefs (Dennis and Lorie Nixon) while others don’t give much of a reason (Kristen LaBrie).  What is your opinion?  Do you think there is ever a reason not to turn to the medical profession?  Is one reason better than the other?
 

Resources:  cnn.com, boston.com

No comments:

ShareThis

Loading